← Crime Talk with Scott Reisch

Mackenzie Shirilla's Appeal Rejected

Jun 24, 2026 · 26 min

About this episode

00:00 Docket 01:01 Intro 01:46 Ohio Supreme Court Rejects Shirilla's Latest Appeal 05:41 Gilgo Beach Killer's Family Rebuilds 09:27 Ex-Colorado DNA Analyst "Missy" Woods Pleads Guilty 14:42 Teacher Broke House Arrest 85 Times, Prosecutors Say 17:02 Kidnapped Teen Found Inside Dryer 18:32 Father Faces Murder Charges After Shooting Daughter 19:53 U.S. Supreme Court Reinstates Conviction 21:53 Legal History 24:04 Quote of the Day 24:16 Dumb Criminal of the Day: Florida Man Sees the Antichrist Mackenzie Shirilla just lost another shot at challenging her murder conviction. The Ohio Supreme Court declined review after her post-conviction appeal ran into a one-day filing issue. Scott breaks down why a procedure can shut a case down before the evidence is even argued. Watch to the end and tell us: strict deadline, or should the court have heard it? #MackenzieShirilla, #OhioSupremeCourt, #TrueCrime, #LegalAnalysis, #CrimeTalk, #Appeal Crime Talk Store: https://crimetalknetwork.com/shop/